If you’re fascinated by the nostalgia of pixel art, classic cartridges, and consoles that changed gaming forever, then retro game collecting might be your next passion. Whether you’re a seasoned gamer or new to the scene, starting your collection can be overwhelming. But don’t worry—we are here to guide you through the essential steps, tools, and tips to become a true retro collector.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover the fundamentals of retro game collecting: where to start, what to look for, how to avoid scams, and how to build a collection you’ll be proud of.
The Allure of Retro Gaming
Retro gaming isn’t just about playing old games—it’s about preserving a culture, a feeling, and a piece of history. From the blocky sprites of the NES to the CD-based games of the PlayStation 1, each generation holds a unique charm.
Some reasons people get into collecting:
- Nostalgia for games from childhood
- Love for gaming history and preservation
- The thrill of the hunt for rare items
- Interest in modding or restoring hardware
Whether you’re hunting for EarthBound on SNES or want to rebuild your childhood Game Boy collection, the journey is as rewarding as the destination.
If you’re new to old-school handhelds, check out Game Boy: The Console That Fit In Your Pocket
Choose a Focus: Define Your Collection
The retro gaming world is vast. A smart way to start is by narrowing your focus.
Common collecting themes:
- By console (e.g., NES, Sega Genesis, PS1)
- By region (NTSC, PAL, Japan-exclusive)
- By genre (RPGs, platformers, shmups)
- CIB (Complete in Box) collectors vs. loose cartridge collectors
Some collectors only care about playable games, while others want pristine boxes, manuals, and inserts.
Looking to start with a major classic? Don’t miss our guide on Super Nintendo Entertainment System: A Timeless Classic
Know Your Market: Price Guides & Rarity
Before you buy anything, familiarize yourself with the retro gaming market.
Tools to research prices:
- PriceCharting.com – tracks market values of games
- eBay sold listings – real-world prices from recent sales
- GameValueNow.com – similar to PriceCharting with more filters
Learn how to spot:
- Reproductions vs. authentic cartridges
- Loose vs. complete vs. sealed pricing
- Console hardware revisions (e.g., SNES 1-Chip, Genesis Model 1 vs. 2)
Rarity doesn’t always mean value—but it often does. Games like Little Samson or Panzer Dragoon Saga fetch high prices due to low print runs.
Where to Buy Retro Games and Consoles
Online Platforms:
- eBay – Best for selection, but watch for fakes
- Mercari, Facebook Marketplace – Often cheaper, more local
- Heritage Auctions, ShopGoodwill – For high-end or rare pieces
- DKOldies, Lukie Games – Trusted retro game retailers
Local Options:
- Retro game stores – Can be pricey, but you can inspect items
- Flea markets – Great deals if you know what to look for
- Garage sales & thrift stores – Hidden treasures await
Always be cautious and check seller reviews. Ask for photos of the board or disc condition.
Condition, Grading, and Storage
Collectors often use these conditions:
- Mint/Sealed – Unopened, pristine
- Complete in Box (CIB) – Game, manual, box
- Loose – Cartridge or disc only
Tips to preserve your collection:
- Use plastic box protectors for cardboard cases
- Store cartridges upright in a cool, dry place
- Clean contacts with isopropyl alcohol (90%+)
- Use anti-static bags for consoles and accessories
Grading services like WATA Games or VGA offer certification and casing, though it’s a controversial topic in the community.
Emulation and Flash Carts: A Collector’s Dilemma
While many collectors focus on physical games, others embrace emulation for preservation and access.
Flash carts like:
- EverDrive (for NES, SNES, Genesis, etc.)
- EZ-Flash Omega (for GBA)
These allow you to play ROMs on real hardware. While not every collector supports this, flash carts are great for testing games before you invest.
Want to patch or mod your ROMs? Try Online ROM Patcher to apply fan translations or custom hacks easily.
Hidden Gems and Underrated Consoles to Explore
While NES, SNES, and PS1 dominate collections, don’t overlook lesser-known systems:
- Sega Saturn – Rich in 2D fighters and shmups
- TurboGrafx-16 / PC Engine – Unique exclusives
- Neo Geo Pocket Color – A true underdog
- GameCube – Becoming more collectible
- Dreamcast – Sega’s swan song
For more on this classic, see Dreamcast: Sega’s Final Console and Its Legacy
Exploring these underappreciated platforms can be both affordable and rewarding.
Join the Community
You’ll learn much faster and enjoy collecting more when you connect with others.
Places to engage:
- Reddit: r/gamecollecting
- Discord communities
- YouTube channels like MetalJesusRocks, John Hancock
- Retro conventions and local meetups
These spaces are great for buying, trading, and learning.
Final Thoughts
Retro game collecting is more than a hobby—it’s a way to connect with gaming history, meet like-minded people, and relive magical moments.
Start small. Stay curious. Be patient. And remember: condition and completeness aren’t everything—the joy of play and discovery matters most.
Whether you’re chasing boxed NES classics or just want to hold a Game Boy again, you’re building more than a collection. You’re building a legacy.